Lean Six Sigma 100%

Green Belt · Analyze phase

Lesson 1: Green Belt orientation and patterns of variation

IASSC Body of Knowledge 3.1, Patterns of Variation · 14 practice questions

0:00 / --:--

Reading

Yellow Belt covered Define, Measure, and the basics of Control: framing a problem, collecting reliable data, and holding a gain once it is achieved. Green Belt is where the middle of DMAIC opens up. Analyze is the search for root cause using statistical evidence rather than opinion, and Improve is where a team tests and confirms a fix before it is rolled into a control plan. Both phases lean on inferential statistics: using a sample to say something trustworthy about a whole process, rather than eyeballing a chart and guessing. The IASSC Certified Lean Six Sigma Green Belt (ICGB) exam covers this expanded scope with 100 graded multiple-choice and true/false questions, roughly 20 drawn from each of the five DMAIC phases, in a closed-book, proctored, 3-hour session with a 70 percent passing score, the same pass bar as Yellow Belt. This lesson opens the Analyze phase with the first tool a Green Belt reaches for when a process shows more variation than it should: figuring out where that variation is actually coming from.

A multi-vari chart for wall-gap measurements across a work day Three time-of-day groups (morning, midday, afternoon) each contain three houses (A, B, C). Within each house a short vertical bar shows the small top-to-bottom spread on one wall (positional variation). The three houses within a time group are offset from each other by a moderate amount (cyclical, piece-to-piece variation). The three time groups themselves are offset from each other by a much larger amount and trend steadily upward across the day (temporal, time-to-time variation), showing that time of day is the dominant source of variation here, not the wall or the house. Wall-gap measurement, three houses per time-of-day batch .0" .25" .50" .75" 1.0" Gap after fill (inches) A B C Morning batch A B C Midday batch A B C Afternoon batch
A multi-vari chart: short bars show positional (within-wall) spread, the offset between houses A/B/C shows cyclical (piece-to-piece) spread, and the rising trend from morning to afternoon shows temporal (time-to-time) spread. Here the afternoon trend dwarfs the other two, pointing an Analyze-phase team at time of day, not the wall or the house, as the vital few X.

Three families of variation

Before running any statistical test, a Green Belt first asks a cheaper question: which of the three basic families does most of the observed variation belong to?

  • Positional (within-piece) variation: differences within a single unit, such as the top of a wall versus the bottom of the same wall, or one corner of a slab versus another corner of the same slab.
  • Cyclical (piece-to-piece) variation: differences from one unit to the next within the same batch or time period, such as house A versus house B versus house C inspected the same morning.
  • Temporal (time-to-time) variation: differences from one time period to the next, such as morning crews versus afternoon crews, or this week's punch-list closeout rate versus last week's.

These three families are not competing theories; a real process usually has some of each. The question a multi-vari study answers is which family carries most of the total spread, because that tells the team where to spend its investigation budget next.

Building and reading a multi-vari chart

A multi-vari chart plots a measured characteristic on the vertical axis against nested groupings on the horizontal axis: several measurements on one unit, several units within one batch, and several batches across time. The result is a picture, not a single number, and it is read by comparing the size of three kinds of gaps: the spread of the short bars (positional), the spread between the bars within one time group (cyclical), and the spread between the time groups themselves (temporal). Whichever gap is largest is where the dominant source of variation lives, and it is almost always obvious by eye once the chart is built correctly, which is the tool's main advantage over guessing from a summary average.

Worked example. In the chart above, the within-wall (positional) bars span about 0.04 inch, the house-to-house (cyclical) spread within a single time batch spans about 0.09 inch, and the morning-to- afternoon (temporal) spread is about 0.40 inch, roughly ten times the positional spread and more than four times the cyclical spread. A Green Belt reading this chart would not investigate wall-to-wall technique differences first; the data says to investigate what changes about the crew, materials, or equipment between morning and afternoon.

Why this matters

Multi-vari analysis is cheap: it uses data a team is often already collecting, reorganized into a chart, before anyone commits to a designed experiment or a formal hypothesis test. Exam questions in this section usually describe a scenario and ask which variation family it illustrates, or what a multi-vari chart is used for before choosing a statistical test.

Classes of distributions: the shape data takes

Once a Green Belt knows roughly where variation is coming from, the next question is what shape that variation's data follows, because the shape determines which statistical tools are valid. Data is first split into two broad kinds. Continuous data can take any value on a scale, such as a measured gap in inches or a cycle time in hours. Discrete data can only take specific values, usually counts, such as the number of defects on a punch list or the number of homes inspected in a day.

DistributionData typeDescribes
NormalContinuousSymmetric, bell-shaped spread around a mean; the default assumption for many measured process characteristics until proven otherwise.
UniformContinuousEvery value across a range is equally likely, with no peak, such as where within a scheduled window a delivery truck happens to arrive.
ExponentialContinuousTime between independent events that occur at a constant average rate, such as the time between successive maintenance calls on a rental unit.
BinomialDiscreteNumber of successes (or failures) in a fixed number of independent trials with a constant success probability, such as how many of 20 inspected homes pass on the first try.
PoissonDiscreteNumber of rare, independent events occurring in a fixed interval of time or space, such as the number of punch-list defects found per house.

The normal distribution and its continuous cousins

The normal distribution is the familiar symmetric bell curve, fully described by just two numbers: its mean (μ), which sets its center, and its standard deviation (σ), which sets its spread. Many process measurements approximate a normal distribution closely enough for the standard tools, covered in the lessons that follow, to apply directly. The uniform distribution looks nothing like a bell; it is flat, because every outcome in its range is equally likely, and it shows up wherever a process has no natural tendency to cluster near a center, such as a random arrival time inside a fixed window. The exponential distribution is used for the gaps between events rather than the events themselves; it is always right-skewed, has no negative values, and carries the "memoryless" property, meaning the chance of waiting an additional hour for the next event does not depend on how long the wait has already been.

Binomial and Poisson: counting successes and rare events

The binomial distribution applies whenever there is a fixed number of independent trials (n), each with the same probability of success (p), and the outcome of interest is how many of those trials succeed. Inspecting 20 completed rehabs and counting how many pass a first NSPIRE-style inspection is a binomial situation as long as each home's pass probability is roughly constant and independent of the others.

The Poisson distribution instead counts how many rare, independent events occur across a fixed span of time, area, or units, when there is no natural upper limit on the count the way there is with a binomial's fixed n. The average rate is usually written λ (lambda). Punch-list defects per house, work-order requests per week, or safety incidents per month are typical Poisson situations in a housing rehab program.

Worked example. Suppose a program's punch-list defect rate averages λ = 3 defects per completed house. The Poisson formula gives P(X = k) = (e-λ × λk) / k!. The probability of a house coming back with exactly 2 defects is: P(X = 2) = (e-3 × 32) / 2! = (0.0498 × 9) / 2 ≈ 0.224, or about 22.4 percent. A Green Belt uses this kind of calculation to judge whether a particular house's defect count is ordinary variation or unusual enough to investigate on its own.

Practice questions

1. Compared with Yellow Belt, what does Green Belt training add in terms of DMAIC scope?

  1. Only a deeper version of the Define phase
  2. Statistical tools for the Analyze and Improve phases
  3. Nothing; Green Belt repeats the Yellow Belt curriculum
  4. Only project management and charter-writing skills

2. How is the IASSC Certified Green Belt (ICGB) exam structured?

  1. 50 questions, open book, 1 hour, 80 percent to pass
  2. 150 questions, open book with a printed formula sheet, 4 hours, 60 percent to pass
  3. 100 graded questions, closed book, 3 hours, 70 percent to pass
  4. 25 questions, closed book, 30 minutes, 90 percent to pass

3. A rehab crew measures the same wall's insulation gap at the top, middle, and bottom and finds small differences among the three spots. This is an example of which variation family?

  1. Sampling bias
  2. Positional (within-piece) variation
  3. Cyclical (piece-to-piece) variation
  4. Temporal (time-to-time) variation

4. Three houses inspected the same morning show consistently different average gap measurements from each other. This pattern illustrates which variation family?

  1. Cyclical (piece-to-piece) variation
  2. Positional (within-piece) variation, since all three houses were inspected on one morning
  3. Temporal variation
  4. Measurement system error only

5. A program's average work-order response time is noticeably higher in July and August than the rest of the year. This is best classified as which variation family?

  1. Cyclical variation
  2. None; seasonal patterns are not a form of variation
  3. Positional variation
  4. Temporal variation

6. What is the main purpose of building a multi-vari chart early in the Analyze phase?

  1. To satisfy an IASSC exam requirement with no analytical use
  2. To replace the project charter
  3. To calculate Cpk directly from the chart
  4. To see, at a glance, which variation family carries most of the total spread so the team investigates the right cause

7. In a multi-vari study, the within-wall spread is 0.04 inch, the house-to-house spread within a morning batch is 0.09 inch, and the morning-to-afternoon spread is 0.40 inch. Which source should the team investigate first?

  1. The house, since cyclical variation is listed second
  2. All three equally, since the chart cannot distinguish them
  3. Time of day, since the temporal spread is by far the largest of the three
  4. The wall, since positional variation is the cheapest source to fix and should be eliminated before larger sources

8. Which statement correctly describes the normal distribution?

  1. A continuous, symmetric bell-shaped distribution fully described by its mean and standard deviation
  2. A discrete distribution used only for counting rare events
  3. A distribution where every value in a range is equally likely
  4. A distribution that only applies to binomial pass/fail data

9. A program inspects 20 completed rehabs and counts how many pass a first NSPIRE-style inspection, where each home's pass probability is roughly constant and independent of the others. Which distribution best models the count of passes?

  1. Normal
  2. Exponential
  3. Binomial
  4. Uniform

10. Which distribution models the count of rare, independent events, such as punch-list defects per house, over a fixed interval with no fixed upper limit on the count?

  1. Binomial
  2. Poisson
  3. Exponential
  4. Uniform

11. If a program's punch-list defect rate averages λ = 3 defects per house, what is the probability that a given house has exactly 2 defects? (P(X = k) = e−λ × λᵏ / k!)

  1. About 90.0 percent
  2. About 22.4 percent
  3. About 5.0 percent
  4. About 50.0 percent

12. Which distribution describes the time between successive, independent events occurring at a constant average rate, and carries the "memoryless" property?

  1. Exponential, a right-skewed continuous distribution
  2. Binomial, which counts successes across a fixed number of trials
  3. Normal, a symmetric bell shape centered on a mean
  4. Poisson, a discrete count of defects per fixed unit

13. A delivery is scheduled to arrive at some random point within a fixed two-hour window, with no time in that window more likely than any other. Which distribution describes the arrival time?

  1. Binomial
  2. Exponential
  3. Poisson
  4. Uniform

14. Cycle times for closing out work orders are measured in hours and can take any value, such as 4.3 or 4.35 hours. This kind of data is best described as which of the following?

  1. Continuous data, which can take any value on a measurement scale
  2. Attribute data with only two possible outcomes
  3. Discrete count data, modeled with a Poisson distribution
  4. Discrete count data, modeled with a binomial distribution

Glossary

Multi-vari chart
A chart that plots a measured characteristic against nested groupings (within-piece, piece-to-piece, time-to-time) to show visually which family of variation dominates.
Positional (within-piece) variation
Differences in measurements taken at different locations on the same unit.
Cyclical (piece-to-piece) variation
Differences from one unit to the next within the same batch or short time period.
Temporal (time-to-time) variation
Differences from one time period to another, such as shift to shift, day to day, or season to season.
Normal distribution
A continuous, symmetric, bell-shaped distribution fully described by its mean (μ) and standard deviation (σ).
Binomial distribution
Models the number of successes in a fixed number of independent trials with a constant success probability.
Poisson distribution
Models the count of rare, independent events over a fixed interval of time or space, characterized by an average rate λ.
Exponential distribution
A continuous, right-skewed, memoryless distribution modeling the waiting time between independent events.